Written by Sarah Connor - Pet Nutrition Expert. Updated on 22/05/2023.
Choosing the Right Shock Collar for your Dog
Our top pick for the safest shock collars for dogs guide is safe, easy to use, waterproof, and rugged enough to use in all terrains. Bark Beyond offers top-notch e-collars to enable gentle and safe positive training without the use of shock mode. Bark Beyond shock collars for dog training feature multiple training mode choices and user-friendly features, making training at home a no-brainer.
In our years of training, we've never had to think twice about safety issues with the Bark Beyond shock collar because these collars are highly customizable for every type of dog. The instructions are easy to understand, and you don't have to hurt your dog when using one of these training e-collars.
A lousy shock collar can scare dogs and quickly turn positive training into a nightmare. As anyone with dogs knows, having a safe e-collar for dog training is essential for effective training. In this review of the safest shock collars, our pet experts spent hundreds of hours testing dog e-collars to check for safety, reliability, and effectiveness.
We scanned thousands of reviews, tested shock collars, and looked at the best sellers with thousands of sales. We've been using our top pick, the Bark Beyond E3 E-collar for the past couple of years.
These shock collars have never failed us, and as professional dog trainers and veterinarians, we can say with the utmost confidence that the Bark Beyond E3 allows for positive dog training sessions that are effective yet humane and 100% safe.
Written by Sarah Connor, an experienced canine trainer and nutritionist for over a decade. Her positive reinforcement methods and passion for pups make her a go-to for dog owners.
How We Evaluated the Top 3
Value for Money
Top 3 Safest Shock Collars of 2023
1. Bark Beyond E3 E-Collar
- 4 training modes with sensitivity levels from low to high
- IPX7 waterproof
- LCD screen with Smart-AI user-friendly features
- Multi-dog training
- Fully adjustable and comfortable collar for small and large breeds
- 800m range
- Easily customizable for each dog (small or large breeds)
- High performance remote
- Multiple levels of low-high beep, vibrate nick levels
- Sleek and stylish
- Affordable for multi-pet homes
"These are a really good set of shock collars for the price. The shock/prong points are actually covered in rubber tips so it helps to protect your dogs skin. There are 3 different settings, beep, vibrate, and shock. There's only 1 sound/noise level for beep and I use this feature the most to grab my dogs' attention, esp if we are out on a trail/off leash. If I call their names and they don't respond, beeping them almost always works."
Professional trainers, veterinarians, and regular dog parents love this training collar because it's so simple to use, well-made, and allows for multi-dog training.
High-quality shock collars like the Bark Beyond E3 E-collar not only offer you the option of training via gentler modes like beep or vibrate without shock but also are long-lasting, waterproof, and feature various training modes. The Bark Beyond shock collar has advanced features like the 800m training range, allowing for "supervised" training and quick recalls when your pup is in danger.
When we trained with the Bark Beyond E3, we found it was gentle enough for small breeds and easily adjustable for larger breeds. The adjustable sensitivity levels and multiple training modes offer pet parents plenty of positive training options. The latest 2023 Smart-AI features don't allow for mishaps, keeping your dog safe and pain-free during training.
Customers like this 100% waterproof e-collar for their dogs because it features various safe and gentle stimulation levels and allows quick response times between remote and collar to ensure timely corrections, reinforcing the desired behavior effectively.
We found that many annoying dog behaviors could easily be changed with the Bark Beyond e-collar via beeping and vibrating modes or even with a mild static correction that does not hurt your dog.
2. Bark Beyond Anti-Bark V1 Collar
by Bark Beyond
- 8 combinations of sensitivity levels
- 3 training modes
- Humane tone-only training mode
- Smart-AI Bark Sound sensors for optimal safety
- Waterproof collar
- Measures: 5.12L x 4.33W x 1.97H inches
- Adjusts to neck sizes of small & large breeds
- Affordable for multi-pet homes
- Uses Smart Bark AI technology
- Best value budget trio deal for multi-pet homes
- Sleek and stylish
"Our little baby would bark non-stop when going outside but with this collar she knows what it is and it has made a difference and she does not bark at all. This has been a huge game changer with us living in apartments."
Customers said the Bark Beyond Anti-Bark Collar V1 works faster and better than most other bark collars. Many customers were apprehensive about using a bark collar but found that the vibration was enough to be slightly annoying without hurting. Users added that these bark collars were the most humane out of all the bark collars, and the beep was loud enough to distract dogs from barking.
The takeaway with the V1 anti-bark collars is that they work well for all breeds that bark excessively while being safe and humane. We liked this no-bark training collar because it offers eight sensitivity levels and three training modes.
The collar is fully adjustable and measures 5.12L x 4.33W x 1.97H inches. It features sound and vibration sensors that only respond to your dog's barking with its Smart AI bark technology. It's also fully submersible and is IP67 waterproof.
Best For Gifts
3. Bark Beyond Anti-Bark S2
by Bark Beyond
- Offers 7 strength level choices
- One-size-fits-all all design
- Automatic shut-off
- Includes 2 silicone sleeves for skin protection
- Waterproof for all terrains while training
- Humane training with multiple correction intensity options
- Lightweight and comfortable
- Easy to use
- Stops excessive barking gently
- Suitable when paired with positive dog training
"We adopted a dog that barked non-stop at night the first couple of nights. We ordered this collar and got it the next day. The collar worked like a charm, and our dog responded incredibly well. We now only need to use the collar sparingly."
The Bark Beyond S2 is another top favorite no-bark collar for all breeds. In 2023, the BarkBeyond Anti-Bark Collar has emerged as the go-to choice for dog parents seeking a humane and efficient method to train their dogs.
The one-size-fits-all design is thoughtfully designed to fit all breeds comfortably. With adjustable straps, this collar provides a perfect fit, ensuring your pup remains comfortable during training sessions. Customers raved about the fast shipping and high-quality no-bark training collar that they received. Users also said that the collars worked like a charm and that dogs responded well to the collars.
This feature eliminates worries about size compatibility, making it an ideal choice for small and large breeds. The takeaway with the Bark Beyond S2 no-bark collar is that it offers humane training with seven strength levels, allowing you to customize the correction intensity based on your dog's temperament and responsiveness. It also provides skin protection against burns and waterproof construction with two silicone sleeves.
This prevents any potential irritation or discomfort on the dog's skin. Additionally, its IP67 waterproof rating guarantees reliable performance indoors or outdoors. This allows you to confidently and positively train your dog in all weather conditions.
How to Pick The Safest Shock Collar
As professional dog trainers, pet parents, and veterinarians, choosing the safest dog shock collar is more complicated than choosing other pet products because using a subpar shock collar on your dog could hurt or scare him. A low-quality shock training collar could also derail your training for months because your dog is now scared, and you've lost his trust.
Consider your Dog's Training Needs and Temperament
Each dog has unique training needs and temperaments. Before selecting a shock collar, assess your dog's temperament and the behaviors you want to address.
Some dogs may respond better to lower levels of stimulation, while others may require a stronger correction. Understanding your dog's needs will guide you in choosing the appropriate shock collar.
Research Different Brands and Models
Not all shock collars are created equal. Take the time to research different brands and models available in the market. Look for reputable manufacturers that prioritize safety, durability, and user-friendly features.
Read customer reviews and look for recommendations from other dog parents or trainers to ensure you choose a safe and effective shock collar.
Evaluate the Range and Features
Consider the range and features of the shock collar. The range refers to the distance at which the remote control can operate the collar. Make sure the range is suitable for your training environment.
Additionally, look for features such as adjustable stimulation levels, tone or vibration options, and waterproof construction. These features can enhance the effectiveness and versatility of the shock collar.
Safety is Paramount
Safety should always be a top priority when it comes to shock collars. Look for collars with safety features such as automatic shut-off timers, which prevent prolonged stimulation that could harm your dog.
Ensure that the electrodes or contact points are made of high-quality materials and designed to be comfortable for your dog's neck. Always follow the manufacturer's guidelines to ensure safe and responsible usage.
Another mistake is using shock collars as a punishment tool rather than a training aid. Shock collars should never be used to instill fear or cause harm to a dog. Instead, they should be utilized as a means of clear communication and reinforcement during training exercises.
Additionally, some pet parents may need to properly train their dogs before using an e-collar. This helps dogs understand the association between the collar and the desired behavior. Introducing the shock collar gradually, while pairing it with positive experiences and rewards, helps the dog perceive it as a signal for good behavior rather than a form of punishment.
Seek Professional Guidance
Our review teams looked into how dog shock collars could be incorrectly used. For instance, one common misuse of shock collars is setting the stimulation level too high. Using excessive levels of stimulation can cause unnecessary distress and discomfort for the dog.
You should always start with the lowest possible level and gradually increase it if needed while closely observing the dog's response. Many users don’t want to use shock mode, and with the Bark Beyond E3, it’s possible to train effectively and safely without the use static.
Pairing Positive Reinforcement With Shock Collar Training
Lastly, using positive reinforcement alongside the shock collar can help the training process. Positive reinforcement, such as praise, treats, or play, should always be incorporated to encourage and motivate your dog to learn and comply with commands.
Professional Dog Trainers
A professional dog trainer can assess your dog's needs and provide valuable insights into training techniques and collar selection. They can help you make an informed decision that aligns with your training goals and your dog's well-being.
Remember, a dog shock collar should be used as a training tool alongside positive reinforcement techniques. Prioritizing your dog's safety, comfort, and well-being is essential throughout the training process.
Safe Training With E-Collars
The need for effective and safe training is very real for dog parents. While initially may seem difficult, positive dog training via e-collar training has many benefits and can save your relationship with your dog.
That said, if your dog continuously fails, it may be due to lengthy training sessions. The optimum training sessions should be three to five minutes in length, three to six times per day, and working on only two or three behaviors each time.
Fixing Bad Behaviors
You can only do this by reinforcing good behaviors and focusing on the good things your dog does each and every day. Timing is key when training, even with e-collar use, and bad timing can create more unwanted behaviors.
If your dog does something you like, you should reinforce the behavior with high-quality treats within half a second. If your dog does something you don't like, you should wait 5 to 10 seconds after he stops performing the unwanted behavior, redirect to a better behavior, and then reinforce.
The most important part of training is to help your dog experience success without fearing training. When training your dog, you should break down each behavior you want to its smallest components to make it easier for your dog to understand the behavior.
When your dog experiences small successes, it builds up confidence and keeps your dog's interest in training. As usual, always use positive reinforcement for all e-collar training and look for added safety features like automatic shut-off to prevent prolonged stimulation.
FAQ's About The Safest Shock Collar for Dogs in 2023
Q: Are electronic dog training collars safe and humane?
A: Yes! Electronic dog training collars are considered safe and humane when used correctly. They are recommended by many dog training experts and veterinarians due to their effectiveness in training dogs while ensuring their well-being.
Q: What is the best remote-training shock collar for dogs?
A: The Bark Beyond E3 E-Collar is widely regarded as one of the best options available. It combines advanced technology, durability, and user-friendly features to provide effective training while prioritizing your dog's safety and comfort. Users said this was by far the best shock training collar they've used, with optimal safety features and training options that allow you to train via beep or vibrate modes.
Q: Which bark collar is recommended as the best choice for preventing excessive barking?
A: The Bark Beyond Anti-Bark Collar V1 is highly recommended by veterinarians as the best dog bark collar. It utilizes eight safe sensitivity levels and three training modes to deter excessive barking, ensuring your dog's comfort and well-being. This no-bark collar features a sleek, modern design and is easy to use.
Q: What is the safest shock collar for large dogs specifically designed to address excessive barking?
A: The bestselling 2023 Bark Beyond S2 Bark Collar is highly recommended when addressing excessive barking in large dogs. This collar utilizes safe and humane methods, such as vibration and sound, to deter unwanted barking while prioritizing the well-being of your pup.Its adjustable sensitivity levels allow for customization based on your dog's needs. The instructions are also easy to understand. That said, if you’ve never used a bark collar before we recommend you working with a positive trainer first.