Best 5 Collars for Dobermans in 2023
Are you looking for the best collars for your Doberman? Look no further, we did all the testing for you.
Written by Sarah Connor - Pet Nutrition Expert. Updated on 22/05/2023.
Choosing the Right Collar for your Doberman
There's no question that Dobermans who understand and react positively to commands have an enhanced bond with their pet parents. And this ties up directly with the huge array of training aids on the market to train dogs of all ages, different sizes, and breeds with individual breed traits like the sensitive and energetic Doberman.
Our dog training experts poured over reviews, tried out dog training e-collars for Dobermans, spent hundreds of hours, and checked out sites like Amazon, Petco, and Chewy. They also wanted the best Doberman training collars that allowed for low stim training and tone-only modes for no shock training to correct behavior gently. We wanted rechargeable dog e-collars with money-back guarantees and good customer service based in the US.
In this buying guide for the best no-shock option collars for the Doberman Pinscher, we found the most humane dog training collars to help positive trainers and pet parents capture their Doberman's attention when they need it most. Dobermans are one of the best working dogs and have excelled in military and police dog work. They also do well as therapy dogs and search and rescue dogs.
This sensitive, intelligent, affectionate, and alert breed is prone to anxiousness with harsh training methods. Bark Beyond products are designed for sensitive breeds like the Doberman and allow for positive training.
Written by Sarah Connor, an experienced canine trainer and nutritionist for over a decade. Her positive reinforcement methods and passion for pups make her a go-to for dog owners.
How We Evaluated the Top 5
Effectiveness
Safety
Value for Money
Customer Service
Overall Best
1. Bark Beyond E3 Dog Training Collar
$149
by Bark Beyond
A+
Overall Grade
Total Ranking
A+
Overall Grade
Pet Safety
Projected Effectiveness
Value
Return Policy
Customer Satisfaction
Features
- Adjustable reflective collar
- 800m range (2600 ft range)
- Includes silicone sleeves to prevent sores and neck burns
- Built-in LED light
- Fully waterproof receiver and remote
Pros
- Swimproof for all-terrain training
- Long-lasting battery life for both receiver & remote
- Duo & trio best value combo packs
Our top pick is the Bark Beyond E3 Dog Training Collar with a waterproof remote for Dobermans. The automatic training system features a sequence of tone and training mode options that teach Dobermans to focus on you.
Besides using a training tone, static, or vibrations to correct your Doberman's behavior, the trainer can train up to 3 dogs simultaneously via the three signal channels. The rechargeable receiver offers four training modes and is designed to be adjustable for all dog sizes with an adjustable collar and 800m training range. The fully waterproof design allows for training in all weather conditions.
40% Discount Code found and applied to our link!
Best for Excessive Barking
2. Bark Beyond Anti-Bark Collar S2
$149
by Bark Beyond
B+
Overall Grade
Total Ranking
B+
Overall Grade
Pet Safety
Projected Effectiveness
Value
Return Policy
Customer Satisfaction
Features
- No-shock option mode
- Lightweight
- IP67 waterproof bark collar
- Spans from 8" to 25 inches for neck circumference
- Fully adjustable for all dog breeds
- 7 adjustment levels
- Easy to use
- It contains two silicone sleeves to prevent chafing
- Includes smart chip feature tailored to your dog
- Ability to customize the intensity and functionality
Pros
- Strong and durable with an adjustable buckle
- One-size fits all collar
- Easily adjustable for all breeds
- Suitable for dogs weighing 11 lbs. to 110 lbs
- Safe and effective
- Humane via vibration mode
- Comfortable
- Quickly rechargeable in 30 minutes for 12 days of use
- Free shipping
Cons
- Bulky on small breeds
When barking becomes an issue with your Dobie, the Bark Beyond S2 no-bark collar is the best option. It works with seven different strength levels and an all-size fully adjustable collar up to 25" for small, medium, and large Dobermans.
The IPX67 waterproof collar includes two silicone sleeves for skin protection and detects barking through vibrations in the dog's throat. This ensures that it will not be activated by other dogs barking nearby. The Bark Beyond S2 effectively curbs barking via a no-shock option.
No coupons found for the product!
Read MoreBest Value
3. Bark Beyond Anti-Bark Collar V1
$59
by Bark Beyond
B
Overall Grade
Total Ranking
B
Overall Grade
Pet Safety
Projected Effectiveness
Value
Return Policy
Customer Satisfaction
Features
- Latest chip with 8 sensitivity levels
- 3 training modes
- IP67 waterproof bark collar
- Spans from 6" to 25 inches for neck circumference
- Fully adjustable for all dog breeds
- 8 adjustment levels
- No false triggering with the upgraded 2023 chip design (15% more efficient)
Pros
- Lightweight with a sleek design
- Easily adjustable sensitivity levels for different environments
- Easy to use
- Quickly rechargeable in 30 minutes for 12 days of use
The Bark Beyond Anti-Bark Collar V1 uses innovative technology when barking becomes an issue at home. This is our top pick for best value anti-bark collar. This no-bark collar for Dobermans features a sequence of tones that teach Dobermans to remain calm and quiet. It's also IP67 waterproof, lightweight, and comfortable.
With this no-bark collar for Dobermans, you can choose between three training modes and eight sensitivity levels to fine-tune your training. This is a long-lasting collar with a sleek design offered in white or black and comes with two pairs of silicone sleeves, short and long, to protect your dog’s neck area.
No coupons found for the product!
Best Wireless Fencing
4. Bark Beyond Wireless Dog Fence S2
$199
by Bark Beyond
B-
Overall Grade
Total Ranking
B-
Overall Grade
Pet Safety
Projected Effectiveness
Value
Return Policy
Customer Satisfaction
Features
- Ability to set up & store multiple geofence perimeters
- Beep tone alert or static shock use
- Smart GPS collar with LED screen
- Offers a shock-free training experience
- All-in-one pet safety & training technology
Pros
- Suitable for up to 3 dogs simultaneously
- Contains & protects Dobermans to keep them safe
- Real-time GPS location tracking
- Includes safe adjustable signal levels
- Over 1,800 positive reviews
The best GPS collar for wireless fencing is the Bark Beyond. It requires no digging to bury wires and covers up to 3280 feet, allowing Dobie parents to optimize their entire backyard when training their Dobermans. It’s also great for hiking, pet vacays, and RV trips to keep your dogs safe.
There's also a rechargeable receiver with adjustable signal levels of corrections, a tone-only mode for positive training, and a no-shock option for training. The Bark Beyond Wireless Dog Fence S2 is also durable enough to withstand all weather, like snow and extreme cold, and all types of terrain conditions, allowing for effective year-round training. The adjustable collar features a clear digital display showing the transmitting signal level, making training easy.
No coupons found for the product!
Best Gift
5. Cosari Dog GPS Collar
$139
by Cosari
C
Overall Grade
Total Ranking
C
Overall Grade
Pet Safety
Projected Effectiveness
Value
Return Policy
Customer Satisfaction
Features
- Live GPS tracking with SMS alerts
- Includes Geofence set-ups
- Uses innovative TopScan technology
- Stores 6 months of route history
- IPX7 Waterproof
Pros
- Best value duo set bundle deal at $230.00
- Check real-time location with Smartphone
- Affordable
- Long battery life
The Cosari GPS Dog Collar monitors your dog's location 24/7. It's more than a pet tracker. The Cosari tracks your dog's location in real-time with Google Maps, transmitting GPS and cellular data while giving you updates on the map. With this collar, you need a SIM card for the GPS collar to work properly. The user can download the app on their Smartphone.
The takeaway with this GPS collar attachment is that it puts the most important information about your Doberman's location right in the palm of your hand with their smartphone app. The Cosari GPS collar is undoubtedly the best gift for all dog lovers. Its advanced features and capabilities provide accurate monitoring and analysis that every Doberman pet parent needs.
This innovative GPS collar ensures you can always closely monitor your Doberman's whereabouts. Its precise tracking system allows you to monitor their location accurately, giving you peace of mind knowing that your dog is always safe and secure.
No coupons found for the product!
How to Train a Doberman With an E-Collar?
We scrolled through our favorite site, Reddit, and looked through Doberman safe dog training e-collar comments to see what professional trainers and Doberman pet parents had to say. We found some great e-collar training advice for Doberman pet parents.
Verified Redditor Comments
"My Doberman didn't have a hard time learning to stay off counters and people, but there was nothing I could do to stop his over the top aggressive barking at neighbors walking by my property. Even if I tried to go outside and retrieve him, he'd run away from me and continue barking madly until person was out of sight! Got an e-collar to correct this bad behavior and it worked quickly."
The same Redditor adds, "My trainer recommended I never use the beeping noise function of e-collar because it can negatively sensitize the dog to beeping noises, which are common in modern life. Basically, he told me to simultaneously use my voice & visual hand signal commands; if that doesn't work, follow with a vibration warning, and if that doesn't work, follow with electric shock, and if shock doesn't work, increase the shock level until it's effective. Of course, always test your collar on yourself first so you know exactly what the dog is experiencing, and use the lowest setting the dog will respond to."
We found this training advice good. "E-collars are amazing because you have the utmost control of stimulus intensity. Meaning you can use just above detectable stimulation to communicate with the dog. The reason why vibrate freaks out your dog is because it is super intense and abrupt and you can't actually decrease that simulation. Don't use vibrate until your dog knows what to expect and what to do when he receives stimulation from a collar."
The same Redditor continues to explain how to use an e-collar on a Doberman.
"To explain to your dog what he is supposed to do when he receives a stimulus from the e-collar, go back to something he knows and is very comfortable with. To acclimate our dog to the e-collar, we first used it as an unconditioned stimulus and paired it with a behavior that he knows and gave good rewards for doing it. You want to condition the simulation such that he figures out when he feels he should be doing that thing. After he was acclimated, we then transitioned him to using it as an extension of our negative markers and now primarily use it as a negative reinforcement."
The Redditor also gives some great training advice on how to use e-collars correctly:
"For introducing your dog to the e-collar, you want the stimulus to be paired with a reward (similar to charging a clicker noise with a reward). So, for my dog's first e-collar session, we walked into a field on a leash and let him sniff. We first needed to see what he could feel. We had already tested the electrical current settings on our palms and went just lower than the lowest setting we could feel. We then incremented up until we saw him react to the stim. The reaction should be really subtle, like his ears direct back at you, or he looks over his shoulder, or he pauses sniffing. Once he reacted, we immediately said his name and his reward marker, "Yes," and started moving backwards with slight leash pressure to get him back to you, rewarding him immediately and enthusiastically. Then free and back to sniffy walk on the leash. Rinse and repeat. Dobes are smart, about 5 to 10 sets of this and he knows that simulation means come get some yummy snacks. And you can drop calling their name and the leash pressure and just be giving him praise and treats."
The Redditor goes on to say, "If you need help understanding this, then you should seek a trainer who knows how to use low stim training. There are some franchises like Sit Means Sit that use the e-collar as escape training, which can be effective but doesn't work for all dogs. There are different philosophies on how to best use this tool. Someone who knows multiple methods and has trained a lot of different kinds of dogs in different contexts (like pet, service, sport, and working) is your best bet at finding a true expert who will be able to read you and your dog and help you get the most out of the tool. Definitely worth getting help with this kind of training. It is a very useful tool, and you don't want to sully it with muffled, unclear training."
FAQ's Best 5 Collars for Dobermans
Q: Are shock collars good for Dobermans?
A: While shock collars have been used for dog training, it's important to consider their impact on Dobermans. Some trainers and experts argue that shock collars can be effective when used correctly and in moderation. However, they should always be used with caution and under the guidance of a professional trainer.
That being said, if you're looking for a training collar for your Doberman, we recommend considering the Bark Beyond E3 Dog Training Collar. This collar stands out because it offers a humane and safe approach to training. Rather than relying solely on shocks, it provides various training modes, including a training tone, static, and vibrations. These options help correct your Doberman's behavior and teach them to focus on you.
Additionally, the Bark Beyond E3 E-collar has a long-range remote and is designed to be adjustable for all dog sizes, making it suitable for Dobermans. With its waterproof design, you can train your Doberman in all types of weather. The collar also allows for training up to 3 dogs simultaneously, making it versatile for multi-dog households.
Q: What kind of collar is best for Dobermans?
A: When choosing a collar for your Doberman, it's important to consider their specific needs and training requirements. While shock collars have been used in dog training, many professional dog trainers emphasize the importance of using humane and safe correction levels and also working with a professional dog trainer when first using an e-collar.
The Bark Beyond E3 No Shock Dog Training Collar is a great option for Dobermans as it offers various training modes, including a training tone, static, and vibrations. This collar promotes positive reinforcement and helps correct your Doberman's behavior while teaching them to focus on you. The Bark Beyond E3 Smart Collar is also adjustable for all dog sizes, waterproof, and features a long-range remote, making it an ideal choice for Dobermans. Remember to always use any training collar under the guidance of a professional trainer and prioritize your dog's safety and well-being.