Written by Sarah Connor - Pet Nutrition Expert. Updated on 22/05/2023.
How to Choose the Right Bark Collar for Your Dog
Did you know there are safe and humane bark collars that can help stop excessive barking? Every dog will have a few behavioral problems, but excessive barking can be the most annoying to neighbors and family members.
Bark Beyond's anti-bark collars make it easier to reduce excessive barking while focusing on positive training. The takeaway with choosing the right bark collar for dogs is finding the best anti-bark collar with multiple training modes and sensitivity levels. By doing this, you can better tailor the collar's functionality to your pup's specific training needs, and not have to resort to shock training options which may be stressful for your pup.
In this review, our experts have spent hundreds of hours looking at how dogs respond to beeps, vibrations, or even mild shock and how adjustable sensitivity levels in bark collars play an important role when combined with positive training in reducing excessive barking.
We spoke to professional trainers, veterinarians, and other pet parents to get feedback on how to choose the right bark collar for dogs.
Written by Sarah Connor, an experienced canine trainer and nutritionist for over a decade. Her positive reinforcement methods and passion for pups make her a go-to for dog owners.
How We Evaluated the Top 3
Value for Money
Top 3 Bark Collars for Dogs of 2023
1. Bark Beyond Anti-Bark Collar V1
- Offers three training modes
- Eight adjustable sensitivity levels
- IP67 waterproof
- Durable & long-lasting
- Stylish and durable with a sporty design
- Includes Smart-AI bark technology for optimal safety
- Trusted by professional dog trainers
- Comfortable, adjustable fit for all dog breeds
- Suitable for Pitbull mixes from 6- 150 lbs
- Often sold out
"This works so much better and quicker then I thought! I have always been against bark collars because of the shocking but I have a dog that loves to bark at everything and figured why not try a no shock collar and with in 2 days is excessive barking as dramatically decreased."
- Verified Buyer
Bark Beyond Anti-Bark Collar V1 is the perfect solution for tackling your dog's excessive barking behavior. Its advanced smart chip technology ensures that only your dog's barks set off the collar, so you can rest assured that there won't be any false triggers from surrounding noises.
Customers liked this no-bark collar because it stopped barking in minutes. They also said that the vibration is enough to be slightly annoying but doesn't hurt at all, no stronger than a phone on vibrate.
We found the Bark Beyond V1 collar to be the best anti-bark Smart AI collar because it was a no-brainer to use, and you can use the training mode that is best suited to your dog's needs and avoid the shock option entirely. These act as warning cues to help eliminate excessive barking, and you know your dog receives a gentler yet effective form of correction.
With its three training modes and eight adjustable sensitivity levels, you have plenty of flexibility to customize the collar to fit your needs best. Plus, its IP67 waterproof capability encourages outdoor use and makes cleaning easy. Choose between the Single ($59), Duo ($97) or Trio ($142) options if you're a multi-dog household.
Top rated in 2022
2. Bark Beyond Anti-Bark Collar S2
by Bark Beyond
- Crafted with a Smart AI Chip
- Crafted with a 25-inch adjustable collar in 2 stylish colorways
- Easily customize intensity & functionality for individual dogs
- Affordable for multi-pet homes
- Includes Bark Beyond's best-value trio bundle pack at $299.00
- Includes 7 adjustment levels
- IP67 waterproof
- Long battery life
- Safe, humane, and durable
- Only responds to your dog's barking
- Often sold out
"This bark collar worked almost immediately and has reduced my dog's barking significantly. While wearing this collar, the dog barks, and there is a high-pitched warning tone. If he keeps barking, there is a vibration. If he continues to bark after that, he gets a slightly uncomfortable zap."
- Verified Buyer
This adjustable collar spans 25 inches and has seven different strength levels to ensure humane training for even the smaller breeds. It also features a protection function with two silicone sleeves that protect your pet's skin from pain and discomfort.
What's really nice about this bark collar is that it's safe and humane and gets fast results. Customers say that they love that the collar is fully adjustable and that they can use vibration and sound for training.
Our experts recommended the Bark Beyond S2 no-bark collar because it features waterproof construction and trains dogs to stop barking via gentle correction modes. This IP67 waterproof bark collar is rechargeable and can even be used indoors and outdoors, all while lasting for 12 days and charging in 30 minutes.
Lastly, this product comes with a 14-day money-back guarantee and free shipping worldwide and is available in packs ranging from single to trio bundle packs for multi-pet homes.
3. Bark Beyond E3 E-Collar
by Bark Beyond
- Multi-functional training modes
- Extended remote range of 800m
- Durable & long-lasting
- Trio set multi-pet pack best value product
- Easily washable with wet cloth
- Trusted by professional dog trainers
- Suitable for Pitbulls and Pitbull mixes
- Includes an LED screen with an energy-saving mode
- Crafted with lightweight high-quality materials
"The BarkBeyond E3 E-Collar changed my perspective on e-collars. It's customizable, comfortable, and yielded remarkable results for my dog."
- Verified Buyer
Customers enjoyed using this easy-to-use training collar with remote because you can combine positive training with distance e-collar training. The Bark Beyond E3 E-Collar is the #1 rated in 2023, and for a good reason – it offers a reliable and efficient way to manage your dog's barking without breaking the bank.
Our experts enjoyed using the E3-e-collar because it provides multiple training modes: vibration, shock, LED, and sound. It's easy to use, safe, and humane via beep and vibrate modes. The takeaway with the E3 e-collar is that you get multi-dog control. The remote transmitter has three signal channels, allowing you to connect and control up to three receivers of the same model. This works well for positive trainers working with multiple dogs and pet parents wanting to train their dogs in one training session.
The Bark Beyond E3 long-range training collar with remote features a waterproof design for all-weather use, adjustable levels of vibration and shock, multiple training modes such as vibration, shock, LED, and sound, and a convenient remote control with an 800m range.
Its user-friendly features include an LED screen, energy-saving mode, and adjustable collar size. Highly rated by real customers - one customer even stated it "worked wonderfully… my dog was barking at 3 or 4 in the morning consistently… disrupting the household and neighbors. The first night this was put on, she stopped this behavior!"
Why Do Dogs Bark?
Barking is a form of communication, and there are several types of barking, each serving a different purpose. PetMD says that dogs, like humans, use verbal and non-verbal cues to communicate.
"They use barking to communicate a variety of feelings, so in order to fully understand what a dog is communicating, pet parents need to contextualize a dog's verbal cues within their nonverbal cues."
Here are some common reasons why dogs bark:
- Alert/Warning: Dogs may bark to alert their pet parents or other animals of potential dangers or intruders. This type of barking is often accompanied by a more intense tone and repetitive pattern.
- Territorial/Protective: Dogs are naturally protective of their territory and may bark to defend it from perceived threats. This can include barking at strangers, other animals, or even passing vehicles.
- Attention Seeking: Dogs may bark to get attention from their pet parents.This can be motivated by a desire for playtime, food, or companionship.
- Anxiety/Fear: Dogs may bark when anxious, scared, or uncomfortable in certain situations. This type of barking is often accompanied by other signs of distress, such as pacing, panting, or hiding.
- Boredom/Loneliness: Dogs that are bored or lonely may bark as a way to release pent-up energy or seek stimulation. This is especially common in dogs without enough mental stimulation and physical exercise.
- Frustration/Excitement: Some dogs bark out of frustration or excitement. This can occur during playtime, when waiting for something eagerly, or when they cannot get what they want.
- Social Interaction/Communication: Dogs use barking to communicate with other dogs and sometimes humans. They may bark to initiate play, establish dominance, or express emotions.
Dogs bark for many reasons, and it can quickly become an excessive habit. The best way to deal with excessive barking is to understand that the most common reasons include under-exercised dogs, boredom, separation anxiety, and environmental triggers.
Taking part in dog sports like canicross, dog agility, running, surfing, obedience, AKC scent work, or AKC Rally is beneficial and helps reduce nuisance barking.The AKC says that you should start by assessing your dog's appearance, health, and appearance.
They add that by doing canine sports with your dog, you become a true team in every sense of the word. Visiting your veterinarian to rule out health issues are also important before using bark collars.
What is a Bark Collar?
A bark collar, or no-bark collar, is a training collar designed to discourage excessive barking in dogs. It is a humane and non-invasive alternative to help your dog understand when their vocalizations are becoming excessive. Dog bark collars allow you to communicate with your dog while providing a shock-free experience by easily customizing the settings.
When it comes to using a bark collar, there are a few things that you need to consider. Properly fitting the collar is very important as too loose or too tight collars can cause discomfort and limit effectiveness. It is also essential to use the appropriate level of stimulation for your particular dog. This will ensure that your pup responds positively to the training without feeling any pain or stress.
Best sellers like the Smart Bark Beyond's anti-bark collars allow for safe and humane training methods with their different intensity mode options and intensity settings that allow no-shock positive training. Now pet parents to excessive barkers have a positive training solution that can help their dogs and stop nuisance barking.
How Do Anti-Bark Collars Work?
Most anti-bark collars operate automatically, meaning they detect your dog's barking and deliver a stimulation without the need for constant monitoring. Dog bark collars are not meant to be used long term but instead shouldbe used as a temporary solution while working with a positive trainer.
This feature allows you to go about your day without closely monitoring your dog's behavior, as the collar takes care of the work for you. Once your dog barks, the collar intervenes with a mild, safe stimulus, such as a vibration, sound, spray, or gentle electric pulse.
On the other hand, anti-bark collars can also work with a handheld remote. In this case, the stimulation is administered when the handler presses the remote button. While this option provides more control over the timing of the correction, it requires the handler's presence and may only be effective if the handler is within the collar's range. With the Bark Beyond E3 e-collar you get a range of 800 meters to work with and have multi-dog control.
Some anti-bark collars feature progressive stimulation levels. This means that if your dog continues to bark, the intensity of the stimulus gradually increases until the barking stops. This progressive approach aims to effectively deter your dog from excessive barking without causing undue stress or discomfort.
Additionally, certain anti-bark collars allow you to manually adjust the stimulation level. This enables you to start at a level that elicits a response from your dog without being overly harsh. Finding the right balance between a stimulus that gets your dog's attention and one that does not cause distress is essential.
It's important to note that anti-bark collars should be used as part of a comprehensive training program, not as a standalone solution. They should be used as a tool to communicate boundaries and teach your dog appropriate barking behavior.
Positive reinforcement training, consistent guidance, and praise can help your dog understand when barking is acceptable and should be curbed.
Positive Reinforcement Approach
Most importantly, when choosing a safe and humane bark collar, opting for high-quality, ergonomic, lightweight dog bark collars like the Bark Beyond Smart AI bark collars that allow for non-shock options is key. You can choose to work with a private trainer at home who will help you understand why your dog is barking excessively and how to handle your dog.
Although this is much more costly than group classes, it's one of the best options for dealing with a behavior problem like excessive barking that requires one-on-one training.
You should work with a positive trainer who will teach you how best to train your pup and use a bark collar. Your trainer will also help you to communicate with your dog and teach you how to use a bark collar correctly.
These anti-bark collars emit a gentle vibration, sound, or spray that catches your dog's attention without causing discomfort or harm. By associating the interruption with the unwanted behavior, your dog learns to refrain from excessive barking in a positive and stress-free manner.
What Features Should a Bark Collar Include?
A bark collar is a valuable tool for training dogs and addressing excessive barking behavior. When choosing a bark collar, it's essential to consider the features that will best suit your dog's needs. Here are some important features that a bark collar should include:
- Adjustable Sensitivity Levels: A high-quality bark collar should offer adjustable sensitivity levels. This allows you to customize the correction to your dog's barking tendencies and temperament. Finding the right balance can effectively discourage excessive barking without causing unnecessary discomfort.
- Multiple Training Modes: Look for a no-bark collar with various training modes. These may include vibration, sound, spray, or ultrasonic options. Different dogs respond better to different corrections, so having multiple modes allows you to find the most effective method for your furry friend.
- Safety Features: Safety should always be a priority when using a bark collar. Look for anti-bark collars with built-in safety features such as automatic shut-off mechanisms. These ensure that the collar doesn't continuously activate if your dog's barking persists for an extended period, preventing potential harm or discomfort.
- Comfortable Design: A bark training collar should be comfortable for your dog. Look for collars with adjustable straps, lightweight materials, and ergonomic designs. Ensuring a secure and comfortable fit will make the training process more enjoyable for your furry friend.
- Water-Resistant or Waterproof: If your pup enjoys outdoor activities or lives in a rainy climate, opt for a bark collar that is water-resistant or waterproof. This feature ensures durability and functionality even in wet conditions, allowing for worry-free training sessions.
- Battery Life: Consider the battery life of the bark collar. Longer-lasting batteries reduce the need for frequent replacements or recharging, providing uninterrupted training sessions for effective behavior modification.
How Do I Use Modes and Intensity in a Bark Collar?
Using modes and intensity settings in a bark collar can help you tailor the training experience to your dog's needs. One of the most important things you can do before using a bark collar on your dog is to understand how to use it correctly.
Try it out on your arm first to test the intensity.We always recommend first working with a positive trainer before using a dog bark collar on your dog so that you can get the help of an instructor. By starting your dog's training in a class setting, you'll also benefit from working with your dog in an environment where distractions are present and your dog can socialize.
Here is a step-by-step guide on how to effectively use modes and intensity in a bark collar:
- Understand the Modes: Familiarize yourself with the modes available on your bark collar. These may include vibration, sound, spray, or ultrasonic options. Each mode serves as a form of correction to interrupt excessive barking.
- Start with the Lowest Setting: Set the bark collar to the lowest intensity level. This allows you to gauge your dog's response without overwhelming them. It's important to note that not all dogs require the same level of correction, so start conservatively and adjust as needed.
- Observe your Dog's Reaction: Pay close attention to your dog's behavior when the bark collar is activated. Look for signs of discomfort or stress, such as increased agitation or anxiety. Conversely, observe if the correction effectively interrupts their barking without causing distress.
- Gradually Increase Intensity if Needed: If your dog continues to exhibit excessive barking despite the initial lower intensity, consider progressively increasing the intensity level. However, always proceed with caution and closely monitor your dog's response. Ensure the increase is gradual and within a range, your dog finds effective but manageable.
- Professional Training: If you need more clarification about adjusting the modes and intensity levels of your dog's bark collar, it is recommended to consult with a professional dog trainer or veterinarian. They can provide expert guidance tailored to your dog's needs and help you navigate the training process effectively.
Is a Bark Collar Safe?
Bark Beyond, a company specializing in training products, debunks the myth that bark collars are unsafe for dogs. They argue that when used correctly, bark control collars can be a helpful tool in managing excessive barking. Bark Beyond anti-bark collars feature numerous training modes and sensitivity levels, as well as Smart AI technology that allows for safe and humane dog training.
Bark collars have both advantages and disadvantages. They can effectively reduce excessive barking and teach dogs to associate barking with an unpleasant stimulus. However, there are concerns about the potential harm or distress they may cause dogs when not used humanely and correctly or when low-quality bark collars are used that may not deliver shock-free options.
If your pup is indoors and barking excessively at everything he sees outdoors, you should obscure the view that triggers the excessive barking. If you see him on a chair or table, you can rearrange the furniture so this does not happen again.
That said, it's important to recognize potential problem behaviors like excessive barking before they become serious. These behaviors may indicate a need for positive training, more exercise, socialization, or veterinary treatment.
Even a well-exercised dog can bark excessively when home alone because they're lonely. The best way to decrease boredom barking would be to provide things like DOGTV, interactive dog toys, and even food dispensing toys in different shapes, textures, and sizes.
When Should I Use a Bark Collar?
Bark Beyond advises using anti-bark collars as a temporary solution for specific situations. While bark collars may vary depending on individual circumstances, they can help address excessive barking in dogs.
The Bark Beyond anti-bark collars work by deterring barking and activating beep and vibration without using shock mode. Depending on the model, it starts with the lowest vibration level and then increases through several levels each time your dog barks within a minute.
FAQ's: Choosing the Right Bark Collar for Dogs
Q: What type of bark collar is most effective?
A: Bark Beyond's best-selling dog bark collars offer numerous sensitivity levels with training mode options that allow for no-shock use and the combination of positive dog training with dog bark collars.
The takeaway with Bark Beyond anti-bark Smart AI dog training e-collars is that pet parents can provide shock-free training when delivering corrections for excessive barking. With numerous sensitivity levels that are easily adjustable, an IP67 waterproof collar, and Smart AI technology, dog professionals found that Bark Beyond anti-bark collars offered the safest and most humane solution for managing excessive barking in dogs.
The Bark Beyond anti-bark collars incorporate advanced features that prioritize the well-being and comfort of all dog breeds while training. One standout feature of the Bark Beyond collars is their extensive range of sensitivity levels and Smart AI technology.
This ensures no accidental triggers and optimal safety while using the bark collar. With easy adjustability, dog parents can fine-tune the collar's response to match their dog's unique barking patterns and sensitivity. This ensures that the anti-bark collar only activates when necessary without causing unnecessary discomfort.
Q: How do I choose an anti-bark collar?
A: The best way to choose a high-quality anti-bark dog collar is to look at product features and reviews. With dog bark collars, one should always test the product on your arm before using it on your dog.
Dog experts found the Bark Beyond dog training brand lightweight and comfortable for all dog breeds to use, and it also allows for positive training without resorting to outdated, harsh training methods.
Q: What is the easiest bark collar to use?
A: The easiest dog no-bark collars to use are the Bark Beyond dog bark collars that feature Smart AI technology and numerous adjustable sensitivity levels, including beep and vibrate, to gently deter dogs from barking excessively.
Professional dog trainers like Bark Beyond dog training products because they're lightweight, fully adjustable for all dog breeds, small and large, and stylish. They're also fully rechargeable and deter barking via beep and vibration modes without using the shock mode.
Dog parents also like the trio's best value pack for anti-bark collars S2 and V1 that allow multi-dog training. Always combine no-bark training collars with positive training to allow for a more balanced and humane approach to reducing excessive barking.
The dual method is suitable for excessive barkers because it will enable dogs to receive a correction for undesirable behavior and to also learn the desired behavior through rewards via positive training. Positive training is more effective and less stressful for dogs instead of only using anti-bark collars.