Written by Sarah Connor - Pet Nutrition Expert. Updated on 22/05/2023.
Strongest 7 Shock Collars for Dogs in 2023
Yup, we adore our dogs and believe in the strongest, most durable e-collars for positive training that are gentle enough for all dogs, even sensitive dogs, as well as e-collars that stand up to wear and tear when enjoying outdoor activities like swimming or playing rough in open fields during those off-leash runs!
An e-collar serves two purposes: They help control impulsive behavior and also help in reinforcing basic obedience like "sit, "stay," "down," "no," and "quiet." They should never be used to punish but instead to persuade your dog to follow through with a cue.
We wanted to find the toughest, most durable, waterproof e-collars for rough terrains, all weather conditions, and dog sports. We also looked at the best anti-bark collars!
Whether you're out for adventure or need to work with a professional trainer, having the best e-collars for training can make all the difference in training success if combined with positive reinforcement.
In this review for the most durable and strongest shock collar for dogs, our experts spent over a hundred hours researching the toughest and most durable e-collars, testing all the models for safety and efficacy, reading reviews, and contacting professional trainers worldwide for their opinions.
Written by Sarah Connor, an experienced canine trainer and nutritionist for over a decade. Her positive reinforcement methods and passion for pups make her a go-to for dog owners.
How We Evaluated the Top 7
Value for Money
Top 8 Bark Collars for Large Dogs of 2023
1. Bark Beyond E3 E-Collar
- Multi-functional training modes
- Extended remote range of 800m
- Durable & long-lasting
- Trio set multi-pet pack best value product
- Comfortable, adjustable fit for all dog breeds
- Trusted by professional dog trainers
- Easy to use
- Includes an LED screen with an energy-saving mode
- Crafted with lightweight high-quality materials
The dog training E3 E-Collar from Bark Beyond makes dog training simple and effective. The system features a remote control that can be used for recall to issue a warning beep or vibration within ranges of 800m. This is our top pick because it features a sleek, stylish design that's also lightweight and comfortable for all dog breeds, small and large.
The Bark Beyond E3 E-Collar is a sporty, lightweight, yet durable e-collar with an LCD screen that makes training easy for dog sports, hunting, competition trails, obedience training, long hikes, and travel. We like this shock collar because it's versatile, trusted, and used by professional dog trainers worldwide!
This high-output multi-mode training collar can be used by beginners and dog trainers and is highly recommended by pros in the industry. It's also equipped with three signal channels, enabling you to train three dogs simultaneously.
With an IP67 waterproof rating, the Bark Beyond shock collar is not only durable enough to withstand grueling outdoor conditions and rough terrain but is also light enough and sleek enough to be comfortable for your dog. Here's the takeaway on the strongest and most durable shock e-collar for dogs.
2. Bark Beyond Anti-Bark Collar S2
by Bark Beyond
- Crafted with a Smart AI Chip
- Crafted with a 25-inch adjustable collar in 2 stylish colorways
- Easily customize intensity & functionality for individual dogs
- Affordable for multi-pet homes
- Includes Bark Beyond's best-value trio bundle pack at $299.00
- Includes 7 adjustment levels
- IP67 waterproof
- Long battery life
- Safe, humane, and durable
- Only responds to your dog's barking
- Often sold out
The Bark Beyond S2 Anti-Bark Collar is designed to gently curb excessive barking. This no-bark collar provides a shock-free experience while offering the ability to set up seven different strength levels to make it safe for small and large dogs.
The Bark Beyond S2 collar is durable and long-lasting and only responds to your dog's barking with its SMART-AI technology. You won't have to worry about any of the usual hassles associated with traditional barking collars—no unwarranted correction or discomfort caused when trying to stop barking!
We like this no-bark collar because it's lightweight yet durable and IP67 waterproof. This means that you can use this anti-bark collar in all weather conditions and train your dog to stop nuisance barking. The collar is fully adjustable for all dog breeds 10 lbs. and over and spans 25 inches.
3. Bark Beyond Anti-Bark Collar V1
by Bark Beyond
- Offers three training modes
- Eight adjustable sensitivity levels
- IP67 waterproof
- Durable & long-lasting
- Stylish and durable with a sporty design
- Includes Smart-AI bark technology for optimal safety
- Trusted by professional dog trainers
- Comfortable, adjustable fit for all dog breeds
- Bestseller in 2022
- Often sold out
The Bark Beyond Anti-Bark Collar V1 is made for dog parents looking for peace of mind while training their dogs humanely. Not only is the stylish and lightweight Bark Beyond no-bark collar ergonomic, but it's also user-friendly.
This no-bark collar features eight adjustable sensitivity levels with three training modes, allowing you to customize the intensity and mode to suit your dog's needs and train gently and humanely.
The Bark Beyond V1 collar is crafted to respond only to your dog's barking. We like this collar because it's durable, and you can use it in all weather conditions and in all terrains. With its sporty look, the Bark Beyond V1 e-collar is IP67 waterproof, with a 14-day money-back guarantee.
Amazon Best seller
4. PetSpy P620 Dog Training Shock Collar
- Crafted with durable thermoplastic polyurethane
- Easily rechargeable
- Waterproof & durable
- Offers 650-yard range remote training
- Free e-collar eBook
- Blind operation design with instant correction-level adjustment
- Receiver and remote 100% waterproof & rechargeable
- Suitable for excessive barking, & aggressive leash pulling
- Good for dogs 10lbs to 140lbs
- The remote doesn't show the battery level for the collars
This is another favorite of ours in that it's priced right and has over 10,000 positive reviews. The takeaway with this durable shock collar for dogs is that you get a free eBook about dog training with an e-collar with your purchase.
The PetSpy P620 e-collar offers a two-bundle pack discount and is crafted with durable, high-quality thermoplastic polyurethane. We like this vibrate collar for dogs because it has 3 modes with 16 levels, and you also get to use the vibration or static correction modes. It also has a beep sound to condition your dog into not needing vibration or static correction!
Best Waterproof e-Collar
5. Dogtra 1900S Remote Training E-Collar
- IPX9K certified (withstands high heat and high-water pressure)
- 3/4-mile remote range
- Extensive range of models to choose from
- Offered in 4 colorways
- Durable, sporty, and waterproof
- Suitable for all dog sports, including water sports and rough terrain hikes
- It boasts a high-performance pager (HPP)
- Crafted with a unique modern design
- Ergonomic slim receiver
- Offers 127 correction levels with gradual & precise correction control
- Pricier than other models
This Dogtra 1900S is an absolute must-have if you enjoy the outdoors. This e-collar is IPX9K certified and withstands high heat and high water pressure. Featuring a range of up to 3/4 of a mile, the Dogtra 1900S allows for short and long-distance training.
This e-collar has 127 low-high controlled stimulations that fit your dog's personality. This sporty dog e-collar works well for basic obedience, hunting, competitive events, or K-9 events. The Dogtra training e-collar offers a nick (quick 1/2 second), constant (up to 12 seconds), and vibration corrections. This is another sturdy and durable shock collar for dogs that is strong and reliable, with both collar and remote fully waterproof: IPX9K waterproof rating.
Additionally, the Dogtra 1900S boasts an HPP (High-Performance Pager), which offers a clear vibration to alert dogs while training. The entire Dogtra line is worth browsing when looking for a high-quality e-collar.
Best for 2-dog training
6. SportDOG 425X
- Fits dogs 8 pounds or larger with neck sizes 5" - 22"
- 25 feet submersible via DryTek technology
- Offers 21 levels of static stimulation
- Lightweight with a sporty look
- 500-yard range
- Suitable for sporting dogs in all terrains and weather conditions
- It can be easily customized for any dog's temperament
- Charges in 2 hours
- Easy to set up
- Durable & long-lasting in rain and snow
- Some customers complained of poor battery life
Sport Dog 425X features 6,600 positive reviews, allowing for two dog training with one remote. The remote range is 500 yards and has a detailed how-to-use manual. SportDog 425X is waterproof and submersible to 25 feet using DryTek technology.
We like this shock collar for dogs because it's designed for ease of use and has a sporty look. This electric e-collar offers 21 levels of static stimulation with medium/high ranges. You have the option to train with vibration (buzz) and tone (beep), too. This model is one of the smallest and lightest training collars built for in-the-field training or hunting with close-working dogs.
Best Small Breed & Puppy E-Collar (6-9 months up)
7. Mini Educator E-Collar
- Suitable for dogs 5 lbs. and larger (neck sizes 6" to 30 inches)
- Includes 100 training levels plus tone and vibration
- Waterproof up to 500 feet
- Lightweight & durable
- Signal range up to 1/2 mile
- Crafted with an LED light on the receiver
- Transmitter floats in water
- Includes PetsTEK training clicker
- Easy to use
- Some customers complained about having to choose between having access to vibrate or the beep and not having all three options simultaneously.
This advanced training system includes the PetsTEK clicker kit and features a range of up to 1/2 miles for complete control and is fully waterproof. We like this e-collar for small breeds and young dogs because it's easy to use, and the battery recharges in two hours.
The collar works with dogs 5 lbs. or more and features 100 levels of stimulation plus tone and vibration-only modes. With momentary and continuous buttons, you can personalize your training more effectively with positive reinforcement. This e-collar works for large field training, backyards, parks, competitions, and police K-9 work.
The Mini Educator E-collar also fits neck sizes between 6 and 30 inches. Assembled and tested in the USA by dog tech training experts, the Mini Educator features a tracking LED light on the receiver collar so you can see while training. Both the receiver and the remote are 100% waterproof. This product has over 4,500 positive reviews.
How to Use a Shock Collar?
Read Instructions Carefully
Before choosing or using an e-collar on your dog, read the instructions carefully, watch YouTube videos, and try to work with a positive trainer first until you get the hang of things. This will allow for no mistakes. Your trainer will teach you how to use low-level stimulation, meaning low power, short-term stimulation that helps to enforce already learned basic obedience cues.
Start Slow and Low
The first step to using a shock collar is to find the right intensity level. Dogs should not vocalize or jump around when using an e-collar. Begin with the lowest level in mini-training sessions and see how your dog reacts. Observing your dog's behavior and adjusting the intensity level is essential. If you jump to a high setting immediately, you can cause your dog unnecessary pain or trauma. Gradually increase the intensity level only when you feel your dog is not responding to the low-level stimulation.
Connect Behavior with Stimulation
A shock collar should never be used as a punishment but rather as a tool to help train your dog. When training your dog with a shock collar, use the stimulation to connect their behavior with a specific command. For example, if you want your dog to stop barking, use the vibration or beep mode and say the command "quiet." If your dog continues to bark, use a low-level shock to reinforce the behavior. Never use a high-level shock or use the shock without a command.
Use Positive Reinforcement
Using positive reinforcement like praise and high-value treats (chicken liver treats or beef patty bits) will help teach your dog to associate good behavior with rewards. This method uses the shock collar as a positive training tool to help your dog understand what you want it to do. After using an e-collar, reward your dog with treats, lots of praise, and fun play like Frisbee. When done properly, this combination of shock collar use via beep and vibrate with positive reinforcement results in optimal training.
Redditors Verified Comments
"So, I use an E-collar on my dog while he's off leash as a backup recall in an emergency situation. I spent months on teaching and proofing recall with positive reinforcement only, then I layered the e-collar. I conditioned him to know that when he feels the stim it's simply means return to me for a reward, same exact concept as verbal recall," says a Redditor user.
"There is no difference in his body language when I use the stim vs when I use the verbal cue, he is excited as hell to come get a reward regardless. The difference the e-collar makes for us is that if there's ever a moment, he really decides to be the predator that he is and zero in on something, he brain is not receptive to sounds and my verbal recall is less likely to reach him."
"But the e-collar tap is something tactile that can break through to him in those moments. I see so much hate for e-collars even just as a recall tool, and I really can't see how the collar could be such a horrible thing when used this way."
Understand the E-Collar
An e-collar is a training tool that sends a signal to the collar, delivering a stimulant to catch your dog's attention. The collar is designed to get your dog's attention and correct their behavior or reinforce positive behaviors. However, it's key to note that an e-collar must be used correctly and safely.
The AVA explains that a dog's perception of any experience that is unpleasant or out of its control may be affected by whatever is causing the behavioral problem.
"Behavior problems can be related to an underlying mental health problem, with a dog showing behaviors that are coping mechanisms secondary to increased fear or anxiety."
All in all, an e-collar should not be used on dogs with behavior issues. Instead, the AVA says dogs with behavioral problems like anxiety, aggression, and fear should receive appropriate veterinary treatment and positive reinforcement training.
Collar shy dogs are most often because of poor introduction to the e-collar. E-collar shyness and aversiveness result from over-stimulation and misusing the e-collar.
Opt for an e-collar like the Bark Beyond E3 featuring a tone, vibration, or beep that can be used as a substitute for electrical stimulation. You can usually overcome this by working together with a professional trainer.
Long Distance Shock Collar
The long-distance e-collar by Bark Beyond helps to control impulsive behavior. The Bark Beyond E3 offers adjustable power levels set from low to high. Remote control e-collars offer long-range training, like training with an invisible long lead line.
Only use the remote collar with proper instructions or under a professional trainer's guidance if this is your first time using one. Watch YouTube videos on how to use an e-collar and research your brand before purchasing.
When using an e-collar, following safety precautions to ensure your pet's safety is essential. Choose a high-quality collar that fits your pet comfortably and correctly. Never let your dog wear the collar for an extended period or when unattended, as the collar can cause skin irritation or pressure necrosis. Always read and follow the manufacturer's instructions on how to use the collar safely.
Pairing E-Collars with Positive Training
If you enjoy the outdoors as much as we do, you know that the most durable and long-lasting e-collar with remote is not only used for obedience training but is an effective tool for keeping your dog safe outdoors and having fun. Although an e-collar can help train your dog, using it alongside positive training methods is essential.
Positive training involves:
- Rewarding your dog for good behavior.
- Treating them with praise and high-value treats.
- Creating a safe, positive relationship.
When using an e-collar, reinforce positive behaviors with a treat or a quick scratch behind the ears. The goal is to teach your dog that wearing the e-collar means good things will happen, and they can feel safe and secure.
Basic Commands Using an E-Collar
Start with basic commands such as "come," "sit," "stay," and "heel" when incorporating the e-collar into your training sessions. Using both positive reinforcement and the e-collar will help your dog learn much faster and become more confident.
At Bark Beyond, we recommend teaching your dogs basic commands before using the e-collar so that you have the foundation for more advanced training.
It's also important to be consistent in your training and avoid punishing your dog for not understanding a command immediately.
How to Choose a Strong Shock Collar?
Shock collars for dogs usually feature adjustable levels of vibration and shock and may sometimes benefit larger and more resistant breeds displaying stubborn behavior that may need stronger stimulation.
That said, not all dogs need a strong shock collar, and their usage should be carefully monitored by working together with a positive trainer. Before using any shock collar, take your dog to obedience training classes to learn the basics of training to avoid confusion later on when working with any shock and vibration e-collar.
How to Choose the Most Durable Shock Collar
As dog parents, we want the best for our dogs. That's why choosing a reliable e-collar like the Bark Beyond E3 Collar is such an important decision.
When it comes to providing safe and consistent training for dogs, certain features of an e-collar make them durable enough to last you years while still being effective at teaching your pup proper behaviors.
A durable shock collar must be sporty, waterproof, and lightweight enough to be comfortable. The best e-collars for training dogs should offer multiple training modes with adjustable sensitivity levels for easier and gentler positive training.
From training dogs to being well-behaved to keeping them protected during outdoor adventures, the Bark Beyond E3 Long Range Waterproof Collar is popular today for its innovative features that cater to various training needs and small and large breeds.
Considerations for Strong Shock Training Collars
Design and Comfort
The entire Bark Beyond e-collar line is sleek and modern and comes in stylish colors that fit your style. It is also adjustable, allowing a comfortable fit for dogs of all sizes. The E3 collar is lightweight, modern, and sporty, with top-notch hardware that ensures durability and easy fit for all-weather use.
Durable Waterproof Design
The Bark Beyond E3 collar is meant for dogs who love outdoor fun! The IP67 waterproof design ensures that the collar remains functional, even when your dog goes for a swim or exercises in the rain. This feature adds an extra layer of security, as we know how excited dogs can be when they see a chance to freshen up in a nearby stream!
Adjustable Shock and Vibration Levels
Every dog has their own unique personality and characteristics, so the Bark Beyond E3 collar allows you to adjust the shock and vibration levels between 1 and 99. This feature ensures that your dog's training experience is safe, gradual, and tailored to their specific behavioral needs. The collar also has four modes of use: LED, vibration, static shock, and sound. Customizing the modes is easy based on your dog's comfort level and training goals.
Battery Life and Charging
The Bark Beyond E3 collar, Bark Beyond V1 Anti-bark collar, and the Bark Beyond S2 feature long-lasting battery life with an energy-saving mode that automatically turns off when it's not in use. The remote transmitter and receiver of the e-collar have rechargeable lithium-ion batteries. The charging time for both is approximately 4 hours. With a full charge, the transmitter and receiver can have a standby time of about a week, providing extended usage before recharging. 800M
Remote Control Range
The Bark Beyond E3, remote training e-collar has an impressive 800m remote control range, allowing outdoor activities such as hiking, camping, and backyard barbeques without worrying about your pup running too far. The remote control also has a user-friendly LED screen, which displays battery level, shock mode, and correction levels information. The remote control has an energy-saving mode, which turns off when not in use, saving battery life.
Adjustable Collar Size
Finding the correct collar size can be challenging, but the Bark Beyond E3 collar features an adjustable collar size designed for all dog breeds, small or large. This feature greatly benefits pet parents with multiple dogs of different sizes needing an adjustable collar size to reduce the cost while providing an effective training tool.
The Bark Beyond E3 collar boasts ease of use with its user-friendly features. It has an LED screen that displays the battery level, the modes, and the correction levels. As mentioned, it also features an energy-saving mode, which is ideal considering remote training can last up to 70 minutes. Other notable features include a charging port and a low battery warning to alert you when it's time to charge.
Strongest Shock Collar for Dogs
Our take on "strongest" means rugged and reliable, allowing for training during travel, long hikes, and sometimes not-so-great weather. We believe in gentle and humane e-collar use, and our strongest, most durable shock collar options show this.
Our top picks offer dog-training Smart AI e-collars that let you train without static, instead allowing you to use beep and vibrate modes. Our best e-collars feature easily adjustable sensitivity levels, beep and vibrate training options, and adjustable collar sizes for all breeds.
Dog Bark Collar
Dogs bark for many reasons, which include boredom, anxiety, and protecting their territory. It can get overwhelming and irritating to dog parents and neighbors. But you can say goodbye to excessive barking with a high-quality dog bark collar.
Dog bark collars like the Bark Beyond Anti Bark V1 that feature Smart AI technology and multiple training modes, including beep, vibrate, and static, and eight sensitivity modes make it easy to train your furbaby effectively without resorting to outdated and harsh training methods.
Dog Remote Shock Training Collar
Dog remote training collars like the Bark Beyond E3 with an 800m remote training range make it easy to train up to 3 dogs. The shock collars complement positive dog training since they bring more control and flexibility in correcting unwanted behavior.
High-quality, strong, and durable remote shock e-collars feature long-lasting rechargeable batteries and a wide-range signal to achieve optimal functionality.
Hunting Dog Shock Collars
Hunting dogs require durable, waterproof e-collars for training and recall compared to companion dogs; this is because when the dogs get too excited and don't respond to cues, this could lead to life-threatening incidents.
The Bark Beyond E3 remote shock collar for hunting and Gun Dog offers several features, making this one of the most reliable, sporting dog shock training collars. Hunting dog shock collars come with more than a mile range and can withstand harsh weather conditions. The hunting dog shock collars work effectively in various hunting scenarios, including treeing, retrieving, and much more.
Strong Shock Collar for Small Dogs
Small dogs require tiny reminders and will not require the same stimulus intensity as bigger dogs. Strong shock collars for small dogs also feature adjustable power settings with adjustable sensitivity levels and are designed to suit the unique requirements of small dog breeds.
The Bark Beyond E3 remote training e-collar for all dog breeds features a sleek, lightweight, adjustable beep and vibrate training collar for dogs 10 lbs and over. Modern dog shock collars emphasize safety first with gentle corrections like beeping and vibration. The impressive 800 m range allows for enjoyable outdoor training with stimulation levels set for mild forms of persuasion.
FAQ's Strongest Shock Collar for Dogs
Q: Does my dog need a shock collar?
A: Always determine if your dog needs an e-collar before using one. E-Collars like the waterproof Bark Beyond E3 with 800m long-range remote outdoor training allow for no shock use, and you can train with beep and vibrate modes.
There are also eight sensitivity levels to choose from via Bark Beyond's 2023 accurate Smart AI technology, allowing for a fine-tuned e-collar that's 100% safer than most other e-collar brands.
Q: What are the highest-rated shock collars that don't hurt dogs?
A: The Bark Beyond Anti-Bark VI dog e-collar and Bark Beyond E3 800m remote training Smart-AI shock collar are best sellers. These Smart AI shock collars work well for all breeds with mild to most stubborn temperaments. Bark Beyond carries user-friendly e-collars that are easy to set up and use and feature adjustable power levels from low to high.